What Is Shipping Protection? What It Covers, What It Costs and Whether It Is Worth It

Shipping protection is an optional fee at checkout that promises a refund or a replacement if your order is lost, stolen or damaged on the way to you. It is sold by the store or by a company the store works with. It does not come from UPS, FedEx or the Postal Service.
Quick answer: It usually costs a few dollars. Whether it is worth it depends on what the store already promises. A seller still has to deliver what you paid for, and a credit card gives you dispute rights if an order never arrives. What the fee mostly buys is a faster, easier claim, and in many plans cover for a package stolen after delivery.
Sources: Route shopper help (how its fee is set), the Navidium listing in the Shopify App Store (self-funded plans), FTC consumer advice on orders that never arrive, USPS Notice 123 (effective October 4, 2026), and the UPS and FedEx 2026 rate guides cited in our declared value posts. Checked November 12, 2026.
Note: the author is not an attorney or a licensed insurance professional. This article is general information, not legal or insurance advice.
What shipping protection covers
Plans differ, so read the terms on the checkout page. Most cover three things:
- Loss. The package never arrives.
- Damage. It arrives broken.
- Theft. Tracking says delivered and the package is gone. Route, one of the largest providers, lists damage, loss and theft.
You may also see it called package protection, order protection or shipping insurance. The names are used loosely. What matters is who pays the claim, which is the next section.
Who is behind it: two very different models
| Third-party plan | Self-funded plan | |
|---|---|---|
| Who keeps the fee | The protection company | The store |
| Who pays a claim | The protection company or its insurer | The store, out of its own pocket |
| Where you file | Usually the provider's site or app | Usually with the store |
| Example | Route, which describes its product as licensed package protection | Navidium, which says the store keeps 100% of what is collected and that it is not an insurance company |
From the shopper's side the checkbox looks the same. With a self-funded plan, the fee is extra revenue for the store, and the promise is the store's own.
What it costs
Route says its fee depends on the order subtotal, the type of items and the shipping method: a flat rate for orders under $100 and a small percentage of the subtotal above that. It describes the total as a few dollars. Stores that run their own plans set their own prices.
How it differs from carrier coverage
Every major carrier already includes some coverage, and the store can buy more. The shipper is normally the one who files those claims.
| Carrier | Included | Cost of more coverage (2026) |
|---|---|---|
| USPS | Up to $100 on Priority Mail, Priority Mail Express and Ground Advantage | From $2.80 for up to $50 of added insurance, up to a $5,000 maximum |
| UPS | Up to $100 per package | $5.10 for $100.01 to $300, then $1.70 per $100. Rises to $5.52 and $1.84 on December 21, 2026 |
| FedEx | Up to $100 per package | $4.95 for $100.01 to $300, then $1.65 per $100 |
Carrier coverage applies while the carrier has the package. A box taken from a porch after a recorded delivery is generally not a carrier claim. That gap is the main thing third-party protection fills. For the carrier side, see USPS shipping insurance, UPS declared value and FedEx declared value.
What you are entitled to without it
The Federal Trade Commission's consumer guidance gives online shoppers a baseline:
- A seller must ship within the time it states. If it states no time, it must ship within 30 days of the order.
- If there is a delay, the seller must tell you and let you cancel for a full refund.
- If the seller does not ship the order, it owes a full refund, not a gift card or store credit.
- With a credit card, a charge for something that was not delivered as agreed is a billing error. Dispute it in writing within 60 days of the first statement that shows the charge.
- Debit card protections differ, and you may not get a refund for non-delivery. Contact your bank quickly.
Those rules do not settle every case. A package that was shipped on time and then stolen from your doorstep is where stores and shoppers argue, and where a protection plan can save you the argument.
Is shipping protection worth it?
More likely worth it when:
- The order is expensive or fragile.
- Packages have gone missing at your address before.
- The store's policy says it is not responsible once the carrier marks the package delivered.
- You are paying with a debit card, where a refund for non-delivery is less certain.
Less likely worth it when:
- The order is small and you could absorb the loss.
- The store already replaces lost or damaged orders at no charge.
- You are paying with a credit card and are willing to file a dispute if needed.
Check whether the box is already ticked when you reach the cart. You can untick it if you do not want it.
If you run a store: three ways to cover lost packages
- Carrier declared value or insurance. You pay per package and file the claim yourself. It does not cover theft after delivery.
- A third-party plan. The shopper usually pays, and the provider handles claims. Route says offering its protection comes at no cost to the merchant.
- A self-funded plan. You keep the fee and pay claims yourself. It works when your loss rate is low and you track it.
Run the numbers before you choose. As an example, if 1 order in 100 is lost or damaged and the average order is $60, the expected loss is $0.60 per order. A fee above that covers the claims. A fee far above it is a price increase by another name, and customers notice.
Two cautions. Insurance is regulated by the states, so be careful about calling a self-funded fee insurance, and ask an attorney how the rules apply to you. And make the fee clear and optional at checkout. For the carrier claim process, see how to file a UPS claim.
Paul's take: Don't forget you usually get $100 of coverage included. And think about what the product actually cost you, not what you sold it for. Everyone can run their own business, but with a premium carrier like UPS, delivery success rates are so high that the math usually points pretty clearly to self-insuring. In my view, what UPS charges for coverage far surpasses the percentage of packages that are actually lost. It's a profit center.
You can be picky, though. A brand new MacBook is highly susceptible to theft, so maybe you insure that one package, while your routine $150 and $200 orders go out on the included $100. And remember, there are all kinds of caveats. If the carrier has proof of delivery and the box was simply stolen off the porch, they're probably going to tell you to go file a police report.
Paul D'Arrigo, D'Arrigo Consulting
Frequently Asked Questions
What is shipping protection?
An optional fee at checkout that promises a refund or replacement if an order is lost, stolen or damaged in shipping. It is sold by the store or a partner company, not by the carrier.
Is shipping protection worth it?
It depends on the order and the store. It is more useful for expensive or fragile items, for addresses where packages go missing, and when the store says it is not responsible after delivery. It adds little when the store already replaces lost orders or you paid with a credit card.
How much does shipping protection cost?
Usually a few dollars. Route says it charges a flat rate on orders under $100 and a small percentage of the subtotal on larger orders. Stores that run their own plans set their own prices.
Is shipping protection the same as shipping insurance?
Not always. Some plans are backed by a licensed insurer. Others are self-funded, which means the store keeps the fee and pays claims itself. Carrier insurance or declared value is a separate thing the shipper buys from USPS, UPS or FedEx.
Does shipping protection cover stolen packages?
Many plans do. Route lists theft along with loss and damage. Carrier coverage generally applies only while the carrier has the package, so porch theft is the gap these plans fill. Check the plan's terms.
Do I get a refund without shipping protection if my package never arrives?
Often, yes. Under FTC guidance a seller that does not ship an order owes a full refund, and a credit card charge for something not delivered as agreed can be disputed in writing within 60 days of the first statement showing it.
Can I remove shipping protection at checkout?
Where it is offered as an option, yes. Look for a ticked box or a line item in the cart and remove it before you pay.
Related Reading
- USPS Shipping Insurance 2026: Included Coverage, Fees and Claims
- What Does UPS Declared Value Mean? Cost per $100 & Limits (2026)
- FedEx Declared Value Fee 2026: Cost per $100, Limits and What It Covers
- How to File a UPS Claim for a Lost or Damaged Package (2026)
- Why Returns Cost More Than You Think
Need a second set of eyes on your shipping costs?
D'Arrigo Consulting audits carrier invoices and contracts for businesses that ship every day. If your shipping bill keeps climbing, get in touch.
Paul D'Arrigo is not an attorney or a licensed insurance professional. This article is for informational purposes only and is not legal, insurance or financial advice. Plan terms, carrier rates and consumer rules change, and state rules differ. Read the terms of any plan before you buy or offer it. D'Arrigo Consulting is not affiliated with the companies mentioned and receives nothing for these mentions. Have questions? Reach out to us.
.png)
.png)